Tonight i saw Captain Phillips with Tom Hanks. As I arrived home my wife asked me: "how was the movie?". my reply: "Terrible".
This was an incredible movie. I shed tears over it. i spent most of the last 45 minutes nervously twitching my fingers. The tension built, and built, and built.... it was almost unbearable at times. my feelings must have been a small glimmer of the hell this man suffered in these terrible hours of his life.
However, this is not why i said it was terrible. There is something much worse in this movie than the American who's life is held at ransom by 4 terrorists. The problem with this movie is also its greatest strength, and that is the horror of the situation no matter which way you look at it. From Captain Phillip's perspective it is horrible, from the Somali's perspective it is horrible.
Life is easy when we can take people and stuff them away into neat little pigeonholes. At dinner tonight, before the movie, i was talking to a friend about this very subject. it is so easy to take a cursory look at someone, asses their visible traits, and make judgement calls. It is as easy as eating donuts and considering ourselves fed. However, like the donuts, this type of judgement works in the short-term, but can be very detrimental over the long-term. Eventually we have to resort to something more filling.
it is not hard, in today's world, to keep everyone at arm's length. facebook enables us to have friends without the emotional investment of any actual, tangible relationship. Texting enables us to communicate without being heard. Movies, TV, and music allow us to commandeer the emotions and feelings of others, without benefitting from the experience of any true emotion. Like the donuts, living in this way will never satisfy long-term. Eventually we must let real emotions enter into our lives.
I am reminded of the allegory of the cave. If i remember correctly, the hypothesis is that once the person is brought out of the cave and presented with a dog, he will not recognize it as such and will, in fact, argue that it is not a dog, but that a dog is the shadow, shaped like a dog, that he has up until now seen on the wall in the cave. We too, as humans, must come out of our proverbial caves. We must, for our own good, allow ourselves to risk hurt by investing in real emotions and relationships. We must learn to call a cat a cat, and a dog a dog. What i mean by this is that we must start to see reality for what it is.
We live in a privileged society. I watch every day as people bicker and fight about trivialities that make no sense. I am no better. I worry about how i will be able to take my kids snowboarding this winter with ticket prices at 50+ bucks a pop. I wonder how will i be able to pay for a big shed i have planned in my backyard, and how i will be able to find the time to go surfing with all the work i have to do both at work and at home.
However, there is a big world out there. Captain Phillips made me think about it once again. I have been to Santiago, Chile. I have seen poverty. I empathize with the plight of the poor inasmuch as i am able. I understand, i think, the cycle of poverty that envelopes the minds and spirits of a large percentage of the world. I understand, i think, the desperation that drives many to commit crimes, against themselves and others, in order to somehow escape their predicament.
I was not prepared, though, to be shown a situation such as what exists for these people in Somalia. I was not prepared to hear that the only work that exists there is fishing and piracy. These were living, breathing people brought to life on the screen such as i have rarely seen. These were people with complex decisions to make, all of which boiled down to a few simple questions: Is piracy worse than starving to death? How far will i go to eat? How far will i go to get some respect?
Yes, folks, this was a terrible movie. It made me remember, again, that war is hell. I hope that i never have to hear about anyone cheering when *spoiler* the pirates are killed. This is ambiguous morality at its best/worst. I see why they had to be killed. I see why it had to happen, but it sure sucks. This situation one where no one wins. Sure, Captain Phillips is *spoiler* returned alive. That is good. However, these Somalis demise was just as miserable as their lives. They live in a forsaken desert with NOTHING around. Their homes and very lives are controlled by ruthless warlords. The men have no power. There is no government. Is literally hell on earth.
In almost any other movie the bad guys would have been pigeonholed. They would be a ruthless band of cutthroat black people, taking advantage of the white people and trying to steal their money. In that movie the SEAL team could have a glorious battle, fighting it out with the last man standing on the top of the boat in a fight to the death with the toughest SEAL. In the end, the Somali would pull some cheap fighting move to which the SEAL would counter-attack, strike hard and fast, and end it with a nice quip about American superiority. That would get the crowd cheering. Captain Phillips is not that movie.
In the end, it left me feeling uneasy about Somalia. It left me mourning all the senseless loss of life and the years and years of benighted hell that will prevail in that part of the year for an indeterminate number of years. How can any good thing come from such madness? I have no answer for you, or for myself.
However, for now i am content to mull it over. I think that is what the movie hoped to accomplish. Nothing is as simple as our prejudices and bad judgement thinks it is.